Ready or Not

Ready or Not revels in expectations—it’s a survival thriller, dark comedy, gross-out revenge splatterfest—but rarely exceeds them, treading well through each genre signifier, as suspenseful and funny and violent as any one of us could hope. Alex’s family, too, serves up plenty of delicious caricatures, all various shades of sly and sniveling: his preternaturally sarcastic brother Daniel (Adam Brody), cokehead sister Emilie (Melanie Scrofano), obviously extremely corrupt father Tony (Henry Czerny), obviously infrequently maternal mother Becky (Andie MacDowell) and sinister, laconic aunt Helene (Nicky Guadagni), who is maybe some sort of sorceror, as well as those who married into the family, Daniel’s equally insincere wife Charity (Elyse Levesque) and Fitch (Kristian Bruun), Emilie’s husband, who has a very Otho-from-Beetlejuice vibe. All congregate for the big wedding, though we learn that Alex has kept his family as little more than a distant reality during the past year and a half he’s spent with Grace, finally forced to drag her to the Le Domas compound now that tradition demands they make it official. Each family member makes their assessment of Grace, efficiently introducing themselves, reuniting with a brother or son or uncle they haven’t seen in some time. Marriage proceeds, and storytelling economy pushes us wonderfully and briskly toward the viscera of the film, giving us all the info we need to feel something when the carnage begins.

It isn’t until Emilie accidentally murders a nanny that Grace realizes this game her new inlaws have dragged her into involves a deadly version of hide and seek. Though Alex tries to keep his family from killing his wife before dawn breaks (unleashing a superstitious catastrophe foretold in family lore), Grace thrives on the relative incompetence of her drunk adversaries at stalking their Most Dangerous Game, able to escape hairy situations by leveraging how little Daniel cares about this whole cat-and-mouse mess anyway. Inevitably, the night gets gorier and gorier as Grace seems closer and closer to surviving daybreak, barreling toward a climax that squanders all bite any of the film’s satire could build. The rich assholes get what’s coming to them, but not because of anything they actually did, only because of their failure to do what they thought they were supposed to do. Grace’s exploitation at the mercy of the capitalistic death machine finds no resolution in her traumatizing wedding night. Even if rich people lose the battle this time, they will always win the war.

Likewise, Ready or Not never quite satisfies its promise to champion Grace as a badass amateur warrior destined to wreak vengeance on the monied monsters who’ve devalued her whole life. The image of Grace in her wedding dress, decked with bandolier and spattered in blood, carries the weight of too many audience expectations, cinematographer Brett Jutkiewicz bathing our hero in rich golden hues, as if there’s something ecumenical to her calling as Angel of Death. Yet, directors Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett never allow Grace a chance to dish out some serious pain, to really fuck up the Le Domas dynasty. She never gives up, never backs down, but never gets to do much in the way of making her in-laws beg for mercy through crushed teeth, massacring them in a Grand Guignol display of blind rage, say, or writhing around in their entrails following some sort of phantasmagoric orgy or something.

Grace deserves to cause so much more harm, and Samara Weaving deserves to do more with a bandolier than wear it as a symbol of reclaimed masculine action hero tropes. Instead, Ready or Not retreats further and further into contrivance, never getting mired in mythos but never having much of anything worthwhile to say about class or genre or how Adam Brody has aged like fine wine, staging its otherwise gentle violence with a lack of flare, the audience mostly wandering down countless hallways, never quite sure where we are or why that matters. We know we’ll get to the point at which Grace gets to watch her enemies burn in the flames of their own greed and corruption. What we couldn’t have known is how little satisfaction that will bring us when we do.

Directors: Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett
Writers: Guy Busick, R. Christopher Murphy
Starring: Samara Weaving, Adam Brody, Andie MacDowell, Henry Czerny, Kristian Bruun, Melanie Scrofano, Elyse Levesque
Release Date: August 21, 2019

Dom Sinacola is Associate Movies Editor at Paste and a Portland-based writer. You can follow him on Twitter.