Possession and The Bachelorette: A Study on the Horrific Making of Men

In both film and reality TV, it all starts with the internal life of a woman. These women—our Bachelorettes-to-be—are like most women; they have emotional impulses that push them to play build-a-boy in the same way that Anna did. Mainly, it’s all in the name of dealing with the torturous emotional rollercoaster of breaking up: The bad, the worse, and the incredibly ugly. The demise of a relationship, or in Anna’s case, a marriage, can be hideous. It meshes and molds itself into something horrible, a mass of maggoty membrane and guts and gore from the innermost workings of love and loss. Once a woman signs onto a show like The Bachelorette, all of that blood and pus starts taking shape, and it is not unlike the horrorshow that was Mark’s clone in the incubation stages. To even try to describe the monster of Possession is to do it an injustice, because the visual is just so garish and gruesome and messy and mangled—truly personifying the ugliness of a breakup.

In case you don’t flex your reality TV muscle all that much, a quick Bachelorette primer might be necessary to connect these dots: ABC whisks one eligible babe out to a resort somewhere special where dozens of handsome, single men are waiting to prove to her that they can be husband material, which is usually what she’s looking for. The series relies heavily on orchestrated dates, hometown visits, highly dramatized elimination ceremonies and, above all else, connection. It is inside that structure that the metaphorical monster of which I just spoke—the gross manifestation of a woman’s damaged romantic past—starts forming into something, something our Bachelorettes hope to take with them through their show “journeys.” Ingredients. These women—like Anna—become fixated on an amalgamation of the best parts of crucial, defining past relationships while also obsessing over how things went wrong. Pretty typical. But it is also implicitly what drove Anna to create a clone of Mark, the husband she seemingly hated the very thought of. It’s what drives our Bachelorettes to relinquish their privacy to reality television in the name of love, where they can assume a position of power to pick and choose the traits they want in a man. The only difference here is that monsters and clones aren’t real; the sentiment, however, is kindred.

In the film, Anna talks about “the two sisters of faith and chance” who are mostly found “fighting in the ring” that is her mind. She and our Bachelorettes have similar struggles, visualizing the before (sister faith) and the after (sister chance) of the breakup. The how and the why and the when. The what ifs. “The possibility I’m talking about pierces reality,” she says during a fervent stupor, trying to reason out her own situation with herself. And though she, and these women who set themselves up for heartbreak on reality TV, can be “the maker of her own evil,” the possibility of a better love with all the best parts of the best times pierces reality in a way that warps things. After all, wouldn’t you say going through the entire dating process on national TV, even if entertaining, is a bit warped? That same possibility warps Anna’s judgement, leading her to build a hellish clone instead of, you know, dreaming big and imagining a whole new lover.

In perhaps the film’s most famous and shocking scene, Anna recounts a brutal and horrific—almost alien—miscarriage she had in the subway while Mark was away. She claims in that moment, she miscarried faith and all that was left was chance—which is basically what it feels like when it all comes to a head, when things hit the boiling point in a split. It’s blood and guts and pus like a waterfall flowing out of your ears. It’s graphic and harsh and transgressive. It’s painful. The scene in the subway physicalizes this emotional moment, which could be considered the driving impulse for Anna and our Bachelorettes alike: The chaos of acceptance. The miscarriage of a relationship and the aftermath, the life beyond. You have to accept the reality of the moment. We see the same instinct at play when our Bachelorettes break down on camera—and there are a lot of these scenes over the years—where they have their moments of catharsis after a contestant they thought was a “better guy” disappoints them. But before coming to terms with the hurt, one must first feel it fully.

It becomes all too much and then…the new match comes into place. The clone starts taking shape.

But ah, there’s the rub. We cannot remake another in one’s image. This is why these romances—the ones our Bachelorettes build with their “clones,” so to speak—don’t always succeed. In fact, we’ve only seen a handful of couples from these franchises go the distance and stay together for the long haul. And for the ones that don’t stay together, well, they go on to become part of the love experiments of others, on and on ad infinitum—just like the Mark clone we discover that Anna has been incubating in her apartment across town. The cycle begins again. The very reason it all began becomes the reason it ends and goes on forever. Some of our favorite Bachelorettes are still trying to find the right guy while Clare Crawley, the Season 16 lead, left the show after just a few weeks because she fell head over heels with one of her contestants.

To be fair, this isn’t exclusive to women. Men, who would like us to think they’re impervious to these sorts of spirals and rabbit holes, do it too. Even Mark projects his fantasies onto the teacher, Anna’s nearly identical clone, which most of our Bachelors also do on their quests for love. Most of those dudes have been hurt, just like the women they’re vying for. But Possession and The Bachelorette share more of a connection than its male counterpart because they are both so deeply rooted in the female experience. Women seem to be more in touch with their emotional core and the root of their impulses—and this is the sentiment that takes center stage in both, despite their vast differences. Told either from the woman’s point of view (The Bachelorette) or with a heavy focus on the woman’s emotional journey from an outside perspective (Possession), it’s hard for the works to not be innately feminine—each meticulously tailored to the female experience in love, heartbreak and starting over.

This concept also extends to the experiences of women on shows like Bachelor in Paradise, Love Island, Temptation Island and their ilk. The majority of these women are going through the same deeply feminine experience. The impulses come from similar places. No matter what, the possibility pierces reality—and that’s how Anna was able to move on. It’s how our Bachelorettes emotionally prepare to craft the man of their dreams—and then craft a life with him as husband and wife—on national TV. It’s how people return to the dating game after being hurt. Wrongheaded optimism drives people to do ridiculous things. In love in an instant; out of love in a flash. But the hope? It’ll make you go mad scientist in the most sickening of ways, and it’ll make you bare your soul to the world in a dating reality series. It will have you trying to create something new from the ashes. But phoenixes, like monsters and messy clones, aren’t real. Hope is. And it’s forever, monsters or not.

Lex Briscuso is an entertainment, film and culture writer who eats, sleeps, and breathes exceptional horror, sweeping dramas, and top-notch acting. She is a news desk writer at /Film and has bylines at FANGORIA, The Guardian, Shudder’s The Bite and EUPHORIA. Her horror radio show, YOUR NICHE IS DEAD, is live Mondays 5pm ET. She tweets @nikonamerica.