Keep Calm, Taron Egerton’s Carry-On Can’t Hurt You

Listen to this article

Taron Egerton would no doubt very much appreciate it if you would take the bait and compare his new, holiday-adjacent Netflix action thriller Carry-On to Die Hard … or perhaps Die Hard 2, actually. And indeed, this is absolutely a vintage thriller in its DNA, perhaps more of a ‘90s homage than an ‘80s one; the kind of flick where a workaday white male schmuck has to rise to the occasion to thwart some seemingly omniscient bad guys while rediscovering the true meaning of … I don’t know, family? Christmas? Unpaid overtime? The point is, our protagonist learns a lesson, shoots some guys and emerges with his life and priorities newly sorted out. The only problem, of course, is that this vanishing breed of modestly budgeted thriller typically revolves almost entirely around the magnetic draw of a star whose easy confidence and charisma can make you fond of the character, even against your own will. And for whatever reason, Egerton is not that star for Carry-On, a film whose protagonist remains an awkward, unreadable cipher from start to finish, dragging down the stronger supporting work surrounding him. His “Ethan Kopek” feels like he should be a minor character in someone else’s film, rather than the star of his own.

The result is a hamstrung thriller that feels cheaper than it should, like a feature-length episode of FOX’s 9-1-1, bogged down by a sense of malaise radiating outward from its protagonist in waves. This is presumably not what director Jaume Collet-Serra was going for when he signed on for what was likely pitched as a relatively “easy” production, considering that this is coming off helming two massive, $200 million bloated studio monstrosities in the form of Disney’s Jungle Cruise and Warner’s Black Adam. Carry-On seems like it was probably positioned as a “back to basics” assignment for the guy, something to replicate the energy of his string of interchangeable 2010s actioners starring an over-the-hill Liam Neeson: Unknown, Non-Stop, Run all Night and The Commuter, many of them also involving mass transit. But where Neeson is never anything but a pleasure to watch as a star, even if perhaps you can’t fully believe whatever stuntwork his double is involved in, Egerton’s enterprising TSA agent faces an uphill battle in making any impression at all.

That’s right: Our hero is a TSA screener at a major L.A. airport, effectively giving him more in common with Lil Rel Howery’s Get Out character than he does with John McClane–again, largely minus the charisma. Ethan Kopek is a mid-30s slacker, disinterestedly coasting in his pat-down, metal detector job for several years after bombing out of his dream of completing the police academy. Just this morning, though, he’s had a fire lit under him: The opening moments linger on a positive pregnancy test taken by girlfriend Nora (Sofia Carson), who also works some kind of customer management job at the airport, the script by T.J. Fixman seemingly lacking confidence that their conversation about her being pregnant will adequately convey the new stakes in Ethan’s life. Regardless, he now wants to make something of himself, anxious about being able to provide for a child and feeling inadequate about not having accomplished enough in his life. Jockeying for a chance at promotion, he requests a chance to work the baggage scanning device at airport security, putting him on a collision course with a deadly–but decidedly overwrought–plot with some well-heeled criminals who need to get one particular package through security.

The voice and face of that antagonistic criminal enterprise is an unnamed character, credited only as the “Mysterious Traveler,” and played with smarmy delight by a decidedly rude Jason Bateman. He’s the one person in the film who truly gets the assignment, and that’s absolutely to Carry-On’s benefit–Bateman is a total pro here, projecting just the right level of Hans Gruber-esque ultra-competence and arrogance as he speaks condescendingly to Ethan via an earbud microphone that is clandestinely put into his possession. Can you buy Bateman winning a fistfight against Egerton, given the 20 year age difference between them? Perhaps not, but it is believable for him to run circles around the younger man in a game of wits, blackmailing him into letting a particular suitcase get through security by threatening the life of Ethan’s newly pregnant girlfriend. If it sounds to you like that probably reduces the character of Nora to a plot contrivance and person-to-be-endangered, then you would be correct, but at least Bateman is having fun playing such a callous, professional character, one who still finds time to revel in demonstrating how much control he possesses over Ethan. The Traveler’s constant stream of quips help keep the film moving, although they highlight the fact that literally every one of the film’s effective jokes comes from someone other than Egerton.

Meanwhile, a concurrent subplot involving an LAPD officer (Danielle Deadwyler) closing in on the potential for an incident at the airport feels curiously detached from the rest of Carry-On, being introduced relatively late in the game and then taking ages to actually merge Movie A and Movie B into the same timeframe. To return to the Die Hard analogy ever-so-briefly, it’s as if John McClane never got a chance to speak with Al Powell until midway through the film’s third act, which makes the entire police presence feel like something taking place in an entirely different film. This time could have been better spent developing more of the other TSA characters who represent Ethan’s peers, like friend Jason (Sinqua Walls), who perplexingly exits the narrative halfway through, never to be mentioned again.

Still, Carry-On is good for a chuckle in fits and starts, primarily when dealing with the easily imagined workday horrors of dealing with irrational holiday travelers in a packed American airport, or the behind-the-scenes camaraderie of the TSA with their bingo cards for items such as confiscated drugs, weapons or embarrassing sex toys. There’s also a few well-executed action sequences, most notably the Toy Story 2-evoking tumble/chase scene through the airport’s labyrinthine luggage-sorting system, which conjures a pleasingly hectic intensity and to its credit seems to feature some actual, physical locations. It’s certainly less off-putting than another CGI-laden fight scene that happens in a car speeding down an interstate, which drives itself so thoroughly into the uncanny valley that even the jaws of life would be unable to extract it. Setting the latter sequence to Wham!’s “Last Christmas” feels like an entirely predictable contrivance, perfect for a film that has absolutely nothing to do with the holiday except for the fact that it’s being released on Netflix in mid-December.

Carry-On is lightweight weeknight entertainment, with a decent enough thriller premise, although one that also requires its blockheaded protagonist to spend most of the film speaking out loud to a potential terrorist while his coworker sitting five feet away never inquires who exactly he’s having these conversations with. If Egerton had been able to bring more panache to the role, had been able to make Ethan someone more engaging on his own merits beyond “expectant father,” it could all be in pulpy good fun. Alas, he can’t keep up with Bateman, who at least knows how to gamely harness the insufferable asshole energy that is his trademark. The casting director may need to be flagged for additional screening.

Director: Jaume Collet-Serra
Writer: T.J. Fixman
Stars: Taron Egerton, Sofia Carson, Danielle Deadwyler, Jason Bateman
Release date: Dec. 13, 2024 (Netflix)

Jim Vorel is Paste’s Movies editor and resident genre geek. You can follow him on Twitter or on Bluesky for more film writing.