The Vast American Gods Will Have the Internet Abuzz About Everything (Except Its Plot)

Gaiman’s novel is a love letter to the patchwork of culture, good and bad alike, that has created the quilt of this country, and the series sticks incredibly faithfully to his version. If anything, it grew closer to the book as production proceeded, and Green and his co-creator, Bryan Fuller (Hannibal), have heeded Gaiman’s input.

“The few times they haven’t listened to me, they’ve had to go back and reshoot, and now they listen to me more,” the author says.

This means a few important things for the series. First and foremost: Boy, is American Gods going to light the Internet on fire, and not just because of its clear support for immigrants’ worth in the Trump era. Even for premium cable television, this show revels in subject matter that will stir up controversy on all ends of the political spectrum. The sight of two Muslim men (one of whom is a djinn) making passionate, tender love in the third episode would instantly incinerate the eyeballs of every Focus on the Family member. Gaiman himself blanched a little writing the version in the novel, and he was surprised that it was reproduced so closely to the letter.

“I got to the point where I’m writing this sequence, I’ve suddenly realized that as a straight white boy I’m gonna have to write hot salesman-on-genie sex,” he recalls. “I remember going, ‘I’m really proud of this chapter… If there’s one thing I’m certain of, it’s that you’re never gonna see that on screen.’ They went there shooting it exactly as written… They didn’t even make up dialogue.”

On the other hand, the horrifying, violent, racially charged ending to the pilot episode will almost certainly inspire a laundry list of think pieces contemplating whether or not Green and Fuller, two white men, even have the right to depict such material.

“We felt it was integral to the book,” Fuller says. “We’re ready to have that conversation… We weren’t just being cavalier about upsetting things.”

As they watched the ending of the premiere, though, Green and Fuller felt they needed to address it immediately at the beginning of the second episode. Hence the appearance of Mr. Nancy (Orlando Jones), the personification of the Ghanaian trickster god Anansi, far earlier in the series than the creators anticipated. In a wonderfully cast show, Jones’ turn is especially inspired, perhaps because Jones grew up with stories of Anansi in his family and understands the comic nature of the trickster god almost innately.

“At the end of the day, you’re a God, you want people to believe,” Jones says. “How are you gonna do that, by yelling? That’s what the con is, the use of that particular tool to get people to do something.”

A simultaneous benefit and drawback of the adaptation’s faithfulness, meanwhile, is that it meanders. American Gods is a long book that intersperses an anthology of short vignettes among the broader contours of an already-loose narrative. Each of the wide variety of old gods—Anubis, Mad Sweeney the leprechaun, the love goddess Bilquis, the aforementioned djinn and Anansi—gets his or her moment in the sun. Rather than pushing these characters to the margins for the sake of the narrative, the series leans into them, with magnificent results: They’re universally beautiful, cinematic, and provide the best storytelling and commentary American Gods has to offer. The multi-episode tale of Bilquis (Yetide Badaki), for instance, is a harrowing take on the state of intimacy in 2017.

“In the sex, I was seeing an individual looking for connection again,” Badaki says. “The idea of this god being almost anemic in the present day… Intimacy is something people are afraid of, that people don’t talk about.”

The way her character solves that problem is by swallowing lovers whole with her vagina, a process that American Gods captures expertly on film, placing the focus entirely upon Bilquis’ power and not upon the lurid act itself. Indeed, sex never feels profane on this show, taking on properties of both the divine and the mundane to encapsulate the spirit of sincere lovemaking.

And yet the mastery of these vignettes makes the plot feel a little secondary, even hollow. Ian McShane’s Mr. Wednesday is, predictably, a revelation—equal parts roguish, wry and threatening, and all with a jocular air that only he can pull off. But it’s a damn good thing he’s so skilled with dialogue, because beyond their admittedly interesting conversations, Wednesday and Shadow Moon don’t do much. This lack of momentum dogs American Gods throughout the first half of its debut season. Riding the line between narrative series and anthology would be difficult for any show, but for one as heady and ambitious and with as many characters as American Gods, the complexity threatens to bog down viewers (especially non-book readers) before they get started.

The series’ creators knew they would run into this issue.

“[It’s] trusting the audience, [which] has always been much smarter than traditional network TV assumed,” Green says. “The book has a spine, but it’s not Homeland. It allowed and celebrated diversions and finding new gears in its own engine.”

That mentality doesn’t necessarily solve the problem—sometimes, even a smart audience needs a strong narrative thrust to become invested—but it does create a tone that screams something to the effect of, “Trust us.” And around the fourth episode, which focuses entirely upon Shadow’s wife, Laura (Emily Browning), everything starts to click. It’s a powerful installment, one composed of material that Gaiman didn’t include in the final draft of his novel. Existing American Gods fans will delight in Browning’s depiction of Laura, who believes in nothing and has no conception of shame.

“I told Bryan and Michael, ‘If you tell me I’m playing the heart and soul of the show, I’m walking away right now,’” Browning remembers. “And Bryan told me she’s the spleen.”

Until Laura Moon gets her breakout, though, viewers will have to content themselves feeding on the richness of American Gods’ musings about faith, sex, culture and the objects of our attention and affection (remember again the way you’re reading this piece). And with the historical moment feeling so… abnormal, the series’ reflective but brutally honest attitude couldn’t have arrived at a better time.

“[My ideas] haven’t really changed [since writing the book],” Gaiman admits. “If anything, I look at American Gods and I wonder how I got that one so right.”

American Gods premieres Sunday, April 30 at 9 p.m. on Starz.